70 Years Ago Today: Elvis Presley Turned a Rejection Into One of TV’s ‘Greatest Moments’

Seventy years ago today, Elvis Presley conquered America’s biggest variety show without entering its New York theater—and Ed Sullivan wasn’t there to greet him. On Sept. 9, 1956, Presley performed from CBS Television City in Hollywood while actor Charles Laughton guest-hosted in Manhattan.

The split arrangement did nothing to weaken the impact. Roughly 60 million people—82.6 percent of the television audience—watched, according to Graceland. That made Presley’s appearance the show’s best-rated broadcast in two years and the most-watched television broadcast of the 1950s, History reports.

Related: 1972 Ballad Made Famous by Elvis Presley Finally Hit No. 1 a Decade Later

Ed Sullivan’s Reversal Cost Him 10 Times More

Sullivan had previously declined an opportunity to book Presley for $5,000. After the singer delivered strong ratings for rival programs, Sullivan and Presley’s manager, Colonel Tom Parker, struck a $50,000 deal for three appearances—the highest amount paid to a television performer at the time, according to The Ed Sullivan Show’s official site.

The reversal captures the real power shift: Television’s premier gatekeeper could no longer ignore the 21-year-old performer audiences had chosen. Sullivan was recovering from a car crash, while Presley was in California filming Love Me Tender.

Laughton sent the broadcast west with six simple words: “Away to Hollywood to meet Elvis Presley.” Wearing a plaid jacket, Presley told viewers, “This is probably the greatest honor that I’ve ever had in my life.” Laughton later closed with, “Music hath charms to soothe the savage breast.”

Next: 58 Years Ago Today: One of the ‘Greatest Songs of All Time’ Was Released

Elvis Presley Turned Distance Into a National Moment

Presley performed “Don’t Be Cruel,” the unreleased “Love Me Tender,” “Ready Teddy” and part of “Hound Dog.” His new ballad gave millions an advance listen, tying the television event directly to his first movie.

The night also complicates the familiar censorship story. Graceland says the first broadcast included Presley’s movement; the famous waist-up restriction came during his third and final Sullivan appearance on Jan. 6, 1957. At that show’s end, Sullivan publicly embraced the star he had once resisted: “I wanted to say to Elvis Presley and the country that this is a real decent, fine boy, and wherever you go, Elvis, we want to say we’ve never had a pleasanter experience on our show with a big name than we’ve had with you.”

Next: 60 Years Ago Today, the Beatles Released an Album That Hit No. 1 and Was Ranked Among the ‘Greatest Ever’

Related: 1984 Dolly Parton Movie, Ranked Her ‘Worst Film,’ Still Produced a No. 1 Hit